The technological advances of the 21st century
have redefined education and triggered a shift in pedagogies towards
e-learning. Teaching – and learning – is no longer confined to the physical
classroom, nor is the way in which students interact. Thus, in the past seven
weeks of this semester I have been able to communicate with my fellow peers
digitally by commenting on their blogs and replying to their feedback on my
own.
Benefits/Successes:
As identified by Maryellen Weimer (2013), collaborative
learning can be extremely beneficial in developing particular skills in
students, such as:
- They can learn content, as in master the material
- They can learn content at those deeper levels we equate with understanding
- They can learn how groups function productively
- They can learn why groups make better decisions than individuals
- They can learn how to work with others
These results can be achieved by either ‘collaborative’ or ‘cooperative’
learning. The difference between the two is as follows:
“Cooperate: the process of working together to the same end.”
“Collaborate: to work jointly on an activity to produce or
create something.” (Morrison, 2012)
I know from my interaction with other peers and blogs that
participation in group work – whether it be collaborative or cooperative –
creates a deeper connection with content, and therefore improves our individual
understanding of a topic. This allows students to improve, as the viewing of
others blogs has the potential to reveal the areas in which one is lacking or
has an overabundance. Comments also allow for suggestions or ways in which the
technology discussed could be used differently, which is useful in a profession
such as teaching.
For example, my Presentation Tools post stated that a
drawback of PowerPoint was that students could skip ahead. Dana, however, made
a helpful comment that there are programs which can inhibit this. Not only have
I learned something new, but it is available for future reference.
Thus, one of the major successes of online collaboration has
been the new information I have gleaned from other blogs. I now have an arsenal
of digital tools to wield in my profession.
I also found that online engagement with others improved
interaction in the physical classroom, as we discussed the blogs, their content
and upcoming topics in tutorials on campus. The benefits of online
collaboration, then, will undoubtedly improve student contact within the
classroom.
Drawbacks/Failures:
While online collaboration has many benefits, it also
suffers from drawbacks.
- The possibility of plagiarism
- The potential of technology failing (eg. a wrongly embedded PowerPoint)
- The possibility of forgetting to reply to a comment
- The loss of tone (potential for misinterpretation)
Another drawback/failure of this task was the limitation of
interaction, as it can be very time consuming. The expectation to read multiple
blogs and leave a reasonable response on each can be overwhelming for many.
Besides, the interaction that did occur was limited due to the Blogger
platform; the author of the blog replying to a comment does not alert the visitor,
therefore leaving the chances of further engagement slim.
Experiences and
outcomes of my limited online collaboration:
There are multiple advantages associated with an online
learning community, both for myself as a teacher and my future students. My
experience with online collaboration via these blogs has aided me in developing
many outcomes, such as:
- Improving my social networks
- Increase in information retention
- Exposure to diverse perspectives
- Increase in higher-level thinking
- Increase in creativity
These outcomes, in conjunction with my experiences, will aid
me in my e-learning design. Having partaken in such an exercise will allow me
to choose pedagogical contributors which will enhance my students learning. These
social network contributors may include:
- Shared whiteboard
- Discussion forum
- Publication (Blogger)
- Groupware (Google Docs)(Anderson, T. & Dron, J., 2014, p. 11 – 15).
I chose these particular contributors as they all allow for student
collaboration or cooperation and the ability to share information in a myriad of
ways. Since all of the aforementioned tools support both synchronous interaction
(real-time communication) and asynchronous interaction (available for a later
viewing), it is possible to establish a classroom and pedagogy in which group
work, and exposure to a diverse range of perspectives, is encouraged (Anderson,
T. & Dron, J., 2014). These forms of online learning communities offer the
advantages discussed in Benefits, as well as ways to improve student
engagement.
Anderson, T.
&. (2014). Teaching Crowds: Learning and Social Media. Athabasca,
Canada: Athabasca University Press.
Morrison, D.
(2012, April 27). Online Groups - Cooperative or Collaborative? Retrieved
from Online Learning Insights:
https://onlinelearninginsights.wordpress.com/2012/04/27/online-groups-cooperative-or-collaborative/
Weimer, M. (2013,
March 20). Five Things Students Can Learn through Group Work.
Retrieved from Faculty Focus: http://www.facultyfocus.com/articles/teaching-professor-blog/five-things-students-can-learn-through-group-work/

Great work Claire! I definitely agree with your drawbacks. I don't believe commenting improved anything for me personally either, the comments are always left after you have submitted it and therefore not allowing for collaboration?
ReplyDeleteJust like this comment... haha Not that you need to listen to comments anyway :)
Thanks Grant! I agree that collaboration is limited by the comment platform. Hopefully Google can fix this aspect of Blogger. :)
DeleteI have to agree with Grant and yourself - the collaboration is definitely limited through the comment platform.
DeleteThanks Louise! Unless you have the time to manually check if the author has replied it is a major drawback to collaborative learning. It makes it extremely hard to meet the criteria in the assessment.
DeleteThis is a very detailed and informative blog post Clare. Fantastic work! I particularly agree with your benefits and drawbacks for collaborative learning and liked your pedagogical contributors for your e-learning design.
ReplyDeleteThanks Brooke! I am a little worried that I have not gone into enough detail for my analysis of the sources, however I did not want to deliver another post which was far too long. Doing so will disengage readers. :)
DeleteI really like how you make clear distinctions between what would work, and what won't (drawbacks). Always a good read!
ReplyDeleteThanks Simon!
Delete